The Pocketbook Thief

Books fill the shelves and display table in a bookshop.

Life rarely grants do-overs. This is one of them.

Introduction

Ever steal a book you couldn’t afford? In this tale from the Second Chances series, an old man returns to a bookstore he once stole from—only to find the son of the original owner behind the counter, with a memory of his own.

⸻

The Pocketbook Thief

The bell above the door to Binder’s Book Store rang its familiar chime, lighter than he remembered but still sharp enough to startle. For a moment, he stood just inside, holding his breath, as if the shelves themselves might recognize him.

Binder’s Book Store. He hadn’t said the name aloud in over fifty years, yet it had lived under his skin all that time—like the small, purplish birthmark on his cheek he now rubbed without thinking, as he always did when nervous. A reflex. A giveaway.

The store had changed, yes, but not so much that he couldn’t find his way. The counter was newer, and there were cheerful little signs — “Staff Picks” and “Blind Date With a Book.” But the shelves in the back? The old sci-fi nook with the slightly warped bottom row? Still there.

He walked slowly, a bundled cloth parcel under his arm. He ran his fingers along the spines as he passed: Fahrenheit 451, Childhood’s End, The Left Hand of Darkness. So many he’d once read in secret. Some he had stolen.

The man behind the counter — broad-shouldered, maybe late thirties, with dark, thoughtful eyes — looked up from a pile of incoming stock. There was something familiar to the face. Not exact, but enough to give him pause.

“You all right there?” the man asked kindly.

The old man cleared his throat. “Yeah. Just … remembering.”

“You’ve been in before?”

“Not for a long time,” he said, stepping closer. “Long enough that the place was run by someone else. Your father, I’d guess?”

The younger man straightened. “Norman Binder was my dad, yeah. He passed six years ago. I took over.”

“Norm,” the old man repeated quietly. “He was good to me.”

A silence settled between them, comfortable for a moment — until the old man’s hand went to his cheek again, brushing the mark.

The younger Binder watched him for a long second, then tilted his head. “You know, my father used to tell me stories about this place. Not the usual ones either. He told me about a boy — quiet kid, birthmark on his cheek — used to come in for the paperbacks.”

The old man’s fingers froze mid-stroke.

“He said they’d disappear sometimes,” the younger man went on. “Only the sci-fi ones. Pocketbooks. He figured they were easiest to hide. He knew someone was lifting them, but he never did a thing about it.”

“I figured he didn’t know,” the old man said, ashamed.

“Oh, he knew,” the son said, smiling gently. “He described you pretty well, actually. Said you used to stand in that back corner and read until your eyes were sore. He always believed if a kid was that desperate to read, he’d find his way to something better eventually.”

The old man swallowed, and for a moment, it was hard to speak. “I didn’t have money. I had pride, though. Too much of it. And a hole in my coat big enough for a book or two.”

He set the bundle gently on the counter and unfolded the cloth. Inside was a small, meticulously kept stack of vintage sci-fi hardbacks — The Martian Chronicles; I, Robot; The Stars My Destination. On top sat a first edition of A Canticle for Leibowitz, its dust jacket pristine.

“I don’t have a receipt,” he said softly. “But these belong here. They’re what I owe.”

The younger Binder began stacking the books carefully, arranging them with quiet reverence.

“I’d like to make a little display,” he said. “Maybe call it The Pocketbook Thief’s Return. It’s a good story, and there might be others who need to see it.”

The old man raised an eyebrow. “You think there are more of me out there?”

Binder gave a soft chuckle. “I think bookstores keep more secrets than we know. Maybe someone else will read the sign and come back, too.”

The man rubbed his birthmark, then let his hand drop.

“All right,” he said. “But keep it simple. Maybe just add: Some stories take the long way home.”

He paused, eyes on the books.

“And some of us do, too.”

The man turned to leave, pausing just before the door. His fingers rose again to the mark on his cheek, but this time he only touched it lightly, as if recognizing an old friend rather than hiding a flaw.

The bell chimed again behind him. Outside, the wind was softer than when he’d come in. The street hadn’t changed much either, but it felt brighter now.

Follow Robin’s Writing

My Facebook stories and Substack articles are now all here. Subscribe for free to receive an email whenever I publish a new story or article.

You can unsubscribe at any time.

Leave a Reply