Originally posted on Facebook on April 4, 2025.
Science confirms that forced right-handedness isn’t just about fine or gross motor control. It also reshapes cognitive pathways, influencing speech, coordination, and thought processes. Forced right-handedness changed me. I do not resent what was done, but I wonder—what would I have been if my left hand had remained free? And how many others, like me, carry a silent imprint or spectre of the self they were meant to be?
(The following is a haibun—a Japanese literary form combining poetic prose with a closing haiku.)
As a child, I was
forced to switch
from my natural
left-handedness
to my right, unknowingly
rewiring my brain.
Decades later,
small habits —
reaching for objects,
arranging items,
holding utensils —
continue to reveal
the ghost of my lost left hand.
Faint morning gesture
the fork turns in my right hand
but feels like a lie
The Hand Left Behind
I don’t remember the first time they told me I had to use my right hand to write. It wasn’t a grand event, not a moment burned into memory like a defining scar. It happened gradually, subtly, yet with enough repetition that, over time, I stopped questioning it.
What I do remember is the mess.
Writing with my left hand left my schoolwork smeared, my fingers darkened with graphite or ink. The side of my hand would drag through fresh strokes, blurring my words before I could finish a sentence. Messy. Wrong. Not how it was supposed to be done.
The teachers noticed. “You’re making a mess of your work,” one scolded, holding up a page where my thoughts had been reduced to a smudged blur. “If you’d just use your right hand, this wouldn’t happen.”
At the time, the logic seemed irrefutable. Writing was already difficult; why make it harder by ruining my own work? I watched my right-handed classmates move adroitly across the page. Their hands trailed neatly behind their letters, never touching the ink. No smudges, no stained fingertips.
So, I tried switching. I held the pencil in my right hand—slower, shakier, unnatural—but at least it was clean. The teachers didn’t care if it felt wrong. What mattered was that it looked right.
And so, the transition happened. Not out of punishment, not through brute force, but through correction, repetition, and the slow erosion of what once felt natural.
The School System and the Battle Against Left-Handedness
In 1950s Montreal, the school system still carried the weight of centuries of institutional bias against left-handedness. Some teachers saw it as a bad habit to be fixed. Others framed it as practicality—left-handed children struggled with penmanship, smudging, and fitting neatly into classroom desks designed for right-handers.
Yet, for some, it wasn’t just about habit correction. It was a moral directive. In Catholic schools, where religious values shaped not just the curriculum but the discipline, the divide between left and right took on deeper significance.
I didn’t grow up in an era where rulers were cracked over left hands for disobedience, but the echoes of that practice and past remained, particularly amongst survivors of Indigenous schools. Left was wrong. Left was awkward. Left was something to be corrected.
Even outside the classroom, society reinforced this. Handshakes were expected with the weapon-wielding right hand—offering the left was considered rude, even offensive. In religious rituals, blessings were given with the right hand, the “hand of righteousness.” The left was sinister—a word that, tellingly, comes from the Latin sinistra, meaning “left.”
As a child, I wouldn’t have known that New Testament passages placed the saved at God’s right hand and the damned at His left. But I did know that every time I reached for something with my left, I hesitated. Every time a teacher took the pencil from my left and placed it in my right, I learned—left was not an option.
The Left-Handed Brain
There was always something slightly different in the way I processed tasks. My organizational habits were scattered, at least by conventional standards, but they made sense to me. I had no strong preference for right or left when using tools or kitchen knives. But subtle things stood out—my fork was always in my left hand, my wallet always in my left pocket, my watch felt more natural on my left arm. I always stepped into my pants left leg first.
I never questioned these things. It was just how I did them. It wasn’t until much later, when my wife pointed out my habits, that I began to wonder.
“You’re actually left-handed,” she said after watching me load the dishwasher. It wasn’t just an observation—it was a revelation.
I had been trained to be a right-handed writer, conditioned into it, but deep down, was I still wired as a left-hander? Had the forced transition changed more than just which hand held the pen?
Neurological studies confirm that early hand dominance is deeply connected to brain lateralization—which side of the brain takes on certain functions. Forced right-handedness disrupts these pathways, rerouting motor coordination, problem-solving, and even aspects of speech processing. Some studies link it to increased stress responses, stuttering, and learning difficulties.
Did I experience any of this? It’s impossible to know. My education progressed without major hurdles (other than disinterest). As a technical writer for part of my career I relied more on precision of thought than penmanship. But a faint sense of misalignment remained—like an unseen adjustment always at work.
A Left-Handed World?
Decades later, I came across an article about Arabic and Hebrew scripts, and for the first time, I saw left-handed writing described as an advantage rather than a problem. In right-to-left languages, left-handers don’t drag their hand through the ink. Their writing hand moves away from the words, leaving crisp, untouched letters behind. No smudging, no strained wrist positions, no teachers hovering with corrections.
It was a revelation. Had I been born into a culture that wrote this way, would anyone have ever told me to switch hands?
In East Asian cultures, where Chinese and Japanese characters were historically written top to bottom, the issue of smudging was different again. Since strokes were completed before the hand moved downward, neither left- nor right-handed writers faced the same struggles. But as modern Japanese text adopted horizontal, left-to-right writing, left-handers began to encounter the same problems as in the West.
In Europe, writing tools reinforced right-handed expectations. Ink-dipped pens and cursive script made smudging a constant concern. A right-handed system wasn’t designed out of malice, but out of practicality—for the majority. And rather than adapting tools, the solution was simply to force compliance.
It wasn’t just about ink stains. It was about reinforcing conformity.
For years, I thought my struggle was a personal failing—an inability to hand write properly. But learning all this made me realize: the issue was never me. It was the system that had no interest in accommodating left-handers.
I had been rewired, not because left-handedness was unnatural—though it was once called gauche and sinister—but because the world had decided right was right.
The Quiet Aftermath
Now, when I pick up a pen, I don’t think about it. The right hand writes, the left hand rests. A conditioned habit, built over time. And yet, every so often, I catch myself reaching for something with my left, natural and uncorrected.
It’s there, in small moments—the way I instinctively reach left first when grabbing a mug, the way my hands move when I’m lost in thought. A buried tendency, dulled by years of adaptation but never fully erased.
My wife notices. She points it out. “You’re actually left-handed,” she says, as if this is still up for debate.
But I’ve thought about it enough to know that’s not quite right. I am not fully right-handed, nor am I the left-hander I was meant to be. I exist somewhere in between, a product of both conditioning and nature.
I have settled on calling it minimal ambidexterity—not in the way that true ambidextrous people can seamlessly switch hands for any task, but in the way my body has divided its habits across both sides. My right hand holds the pen, my left reaches first. My right throws a ball, my left catches instinctively. My right adapts to a world designed for it, but my left refuses to fully disappear.
One hand trained, the other lingering in the shadows of its former self.
It is neither a burden nor a loss, simply a quiet reality of how I move through the world.
In the end, though, maybe none of this matters anymore. Handwriting is fading—replaced by keyboards, touchscreens, and voice-to-text. Whether left-handed, right-handed, or somewhere in between, we now type more than we write, our fingers tapping across glass and plastic instead of pressing ink to paper. The old battle over which hand holds the pen has faded into irrelevance. And yet, for those of us who once had our hands forcibly reshaped, the imprint remains—not just in how we write, but in how we move, how we reach, how we navigate a world still full of objects and infrastructure designed for the right-handed majority, that once told us we were using the wrong hand.
Author’s Note
Mixed handedness—using different hands for different tasks—is not the same as ambidexterity. While ambidextrous individuals can perform most tasks equally well with either hand, mixed-handed people often develop specific, consistent patterns across daily routines. Research suggests this trait may result from early-life hand switching, as occurred widely in mid-20th century classrooms. Studies in neuropsychology indicate that such interventions can subtly reshape brain organization, influencing motor skills, attention, and even memory. Though often overlooked, mixed handedness is a recognized and lasting outcome of forced conformity—one that quietly endures in how we navigate the physical world.
Special thanks to my editor Hendrik de Pagter.
If you enjoyed this story
A personal memory and a story about two brothers show two ways of bringing prose and haiku together.

Leave a Reply